I.
Problem/Issue Statement
a)
Xan Salgado Badas and Bruno Sanchez are
discussing the POS terminals used by Zara’s, Inditex’s largest chain of
stores. Inditex is a multinational
clothing retailer and manufacturer headquartered in La Coruña, Spain. Salgado was the head of IT for Inditex and
Sanchez was the technical lead for the POS system. They cannot agree on whether or not to change
their POS terminals. Both have strong
opinions regarding their position on the debate and are not going to give in to
the other’s opinion. Salgado believes it
is time to upgrade the POS application while Sanchez believed that there wasn’t
a need to fix what wasn’t broken as the POS application was working just fine
for them.
b)
The problem that is being discussed is whether
or not to change the POS terminals used by Zara. Salgado believes it is time to upgrade them
as it is risky to let them get so far behind current technology. Sanchez, on the other hand, believes it is
riskier to change them as the software works just fine.
The
symptoms that have brought up this discussion are as follows:
o Per
Salgado: There is a need to upgrade the POS as they currently run on DOS, which
is no longer supported by Microsoft. He
believes there is a possibility that the hardware vendor could upgrade their
machines and could potentially change it so that it would no longer be compatible
with DOS. Salgado also pointed out that
managers were asking for the change. They
(managers) wanted to be able to look up inventory balances in their stores and
other stores. An upgrade would allow them
to have a well-rounded system which would allow them to interconnect/ change
with other stores.
o Per Sanchez: There are no symptoms that warrant the need
to upgrade Zara’s POS terminals. The
software is working for Zara and there is no need to change it.
c)
This problem involves all Zara stores,
approximately 550. The resolution to
this problem will impact all operations related to the Zara stores. If Sanchez gets Salgado to agree with him,
the POS terminals at the stores would have to be upgraded.
a)
In order to decide which alternative is most
suitable for the company, Sanchez and Salgado must consider the following:
o Cost
of both alternatives
§ Software
§ Support
§ Training
o Risks
associated to the alternatives
§ Risk
of continuing to run on DOS, which is no longer supported by Microsoft
§ Risk
of data loss
§ Risk
of messing up a process that is currently seamless
o Benefits
of each alternative
§ No
change:
·
Maintaining a process that is currently
working
·
Cost savings – no added cost/ effort
·
Employee knowledge of the current DOS terminals
·
No IT involvement when new stores are opened
§ Upgrading:
·
Added functionality such as real-time
inventory across all locations
·
Networking capability
o Changes related to each alternative:
§ Training
required
§ Process
modification
III.
Alternatives
a)
There are two
options for Zara at this point. It would
be to either upgrade Zara’s POS terminals or keep everything status quo.
Per Sanchez: He
recommends keeping everything status quo at this point without making any
changes. Given Salgado’s concern related
to DOS compatibility, Sanchez recommends purchasing a bunch of the current
terminals which would provide them with breathing room should such a case
arise.
b)
The alternatives
address the problem at hand as follows:
Upgrade: A software
upgrade for Zara’s POS terminals would enable the company and stores to
interact with one another. It would also
facilitate the store operations, particularly the ordering process. Store managers would be able to process
orders online versus having to use the digital handheld. Having the form available online would facilitate
the process as they would be able to see the pictures of the garments more
clearly. As reflected in Exhibit 8, the
handhelds currently being used are very compact and do not provide the same
level of display as a computer would if the POS terminals went through an
upgrade. The upgrade would also allow
managers to look up their inventory on the computer without having to do a
visual inspection. I would visualize the
ordering process as follows if the upgrade is implemented:
o Current inventory available on terminals
o
Ordering window
announced and form is made available
§ Provide the store managers with the same data
currently being provided
o
Order approved/
modified at La Coruña
o
Inventory automatically updated after order
had been finalized/ order received
Status Quo: By keeping everything intact, Zara would continue
to operate using their basic POS application.
Zara’s would save money and would be able to invest money in new
locations as opposed to new software/ training related to upgrading the POS terminals. By continuing operations as currently in
place, IT’s involvement would not be required when opening new stores and
in-house support would be available for any IT issues that arise related to the
DOS terminals.
Given
the insight on Zara’s operations, I believe it would be best for Zara’s to
continue using their current POS terminals and forego the upgrade. I agree with Sanchez, it is not worth fixing
what is not broken. The implementation
of an upgrade would be added cost for Zara’s at this point. It would also be added effort to designate a
team dedicated to this upgrade. The
upgrade would require the team to collaborate to understand what changes would
be needed and what would work best for Zara’s. After deciding and implementing
the changes, they would also have to roll out training to introduce the new
software. All these added costs are not
necessary at the time and this money would be better spent with other
initiatives that require Zara’s attention at this time.
