Problem/Issue Statement
Bombardier was a key player in the transportation industry which entered the rail transportation market in 1974 and also entered the aerospace industry in 1986. In an effort to increase its market share, Bombardier continued to acquire several corporations, including Canadair, the leading Canadian aircraft manufacturer, Lear Jet Corporation and Havilland Company. Bombardier reported revenues of $14.8 Billion in 2007. Revenues were evenly split between the aerospace and transportation industries.
While the company was profitable and competitive, it faced several challenges related to the size of the business and its acquisitions. Bombardier’s growth by acquisition generated some challenges for the business. The multiple acquisitions resulted in various simultaneous systems for Bombardier. As a result of the various acquisitions, Bombardier inherited the data, processes and systems of each company it acquired. These inheritances created inefficiencies and problems for Bombardier. The various systems did not communicate or integrate with one another, therefore, resulting in difficulties for the business.
The standalone systems made it difficult given the various differences. It was difficult for the systems to share data and analytics were also challenging. Additionally, the upkeep and maintenance of the systems was costly. Costs were multiplied by the number of systems given the lack of standardization. These inefficiencies resulted in process delays, sequential activities, low inventory turns as well as multiple bills of material. Most importantly, Bombardier’s most challenging task at hand was low visibility of inventory and lack of integration between its legacy systems.
In an effort to strategically align the company, Bombardier took several steps in addressing the issues at hand. They implemented common roles and responsibilities as well as common company values. They also used Six Sigma tools for the evaluation of processes. Bombardier’s desired outcome was an integrated organization where company data could be shared across the company using a single set of processes and systems. The implementation of an ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) system was considered the most beneficial in attaining the company’s goal.
Situation Assessment
Bombardier has gone through two implementation phases of the ERP system. The first ERP implementation was discontinued mid-project. Some of the factors that contributed to its failure were focus on inappropriate business processes, an outdated company vision, a weak sponsorship model, and insufficient involvement of internal employees. The second ERP implementation went live on the planned date and there were no significant disruptions to normal operations. There were no real problems during Go Live and a high rate of accuracy was achieved. However, employees provided feedback post Go-Live after being able to “live” with the system for some time. They were able to share feedback which would facilitate further implementation and increase the value obtained from the system.
In order to fully integrate the business and accomplish its “One Company” goal, Bombardier is rolling out a third phase of the ERP implementation. During this third phase, Bombardier hopes to accomplish a full business integration as well as efficiency and effectiveness throughout their operations. Given Bombardier’s prior experience with the ERP implementation, they hope to utilize lessons learned and results from the previous two phases in order to achieve their desired results during this phase.
List of Plausible Alternative Courses of Action
In order for Bombardier to successfully implement the third phase of the ERP implementation, I would offer the following recommendations:
· Secure Top Management and Leadership endorsement - By obtaining top leadership’s endorsement, the project’s importance and relevance will be reflected to employees. An approach similar to the VP of Operations and Project Sponsor which believed that “we all have a pay cheque that says the word Bombardier on it and shouldn’t forget that.” This message should be emphasized throughout the project to ensure employees understand that they are critical to the success of the ERP which in the end which benefit all, not just management and leadership.
· Assign a full-time project manager – By assigning a full-time project manager, the ERP implementation would be more effective and smooth. A dedicated employee would be focused in the success of this rollout and would be able to gather ongoing feedback and work to resolve any issues that arise. The project manager can also be in charge of continuously providing updates, resolutions and recommendation based on the overall business needs.
· Engage end users frequently – It is imperative that all involved parties are represented and empowered throughout the process. End users know their job best and can provide useful and beneficial information that will decrease the risk of failure throughout the project. Having representation is important to be able to understand all aspects of the business.
· Provide on-going communication – Communication should be prioritized during all implementations. It is extremely important to keep all involved parties up to date as related to project status, issues, risks, observations and overall progress to ensure the team is kept informed of all relevant data related to the project.
· Obtain representation from all functional areas – Given the various roles throughout the company, it would benefit the company to obtain representation from the various sites/ functions that will be impacted by the ERP implementation. It is important to ensure all business needs are understood and planned for to avoid any hiccups in the long run.
· Provide training throughout the implementation – Training is a critical component of the success of any new implementation. It will be useful to provide ongoing training to the involved parties to ensure the system is understood and aligned to business needs. Training should be provided to the project to ensure they understand the capabilities of the ERP system. An understanding of the system will allow them to make informed decisions for the success of the ERP rollout.
Recommendation
Overall, Bombardier has the necessary tools, most importantly experience gained firsthand, to accomplish its goal. The third phase of the ERP implementation should take into consideration lessons learned from the first two phases as well as the recommendations provided above. In doing so, Bombardier will be able to establish a new baseline for the company. In order to successfully implement phase three of the ERP, Bombardier should strive for ongoing communication, involvement and integration to ensure its benefits are maximized and well received.
Post-Presentation Reflection
Post-Presentation Reflection
I have reflected on the consultant’s
presentation over the past few days and I have come to a conclusion for our
team going forward. The consultant’s
presentation was insightful and thought provoking. I really valued their analysis of the 12 best
practices. It was definitely interesting
to see how their scored our team as related to the 12 best practices. There were some instances in which agreed with
their scoring while there were also some that I disagreed with – especially the
one related to the reassignment of our project team member’s full time
responsibilities. After our discussion
with the consultants on this topic, I believe that this is easier said than
done. Our project team members would not
be able to reassign their daily responsibilities, this would have to be worked
out to ensure we provide the team members with the support needed in order to
fulfill their duties.
The recommendations provided by
the consultants were thoroughly presented and discussed for our understanding. After considering the information provided to
us by the consultants, I would recommend that our team focus on best practices
#3 and #6 to ensure inclusion and cohesiveness during the ERP implementation as
well as best practice #9 to ensure SAP is developed and maintained
in-house. To address best practices #3
and #6, I would suggest our team go for recommended course of action #1:
functional specialists included in project management team. Following this course of action would benefit
our team and allow us to ensure collaboration and diversification in our
project. By including functional specialists
in our project team, our implementation would be aligned and structured for
success by allowing all functional areas a voice in the project. With respect to best practice #9, I believe
recommended course of action would suggest a blend of options 2 and 3. Option #2 relates to securing access to the
SAP knowledge base for SAP developers and Option #3 relates to hiring 3 SAP
SMEs. I believe that we must provide our
project with access to the knowledge base regardless of any other actions we
take. Access to the SAP knowledge base
will be a valuable resource for our team and should be provided to at least one
functional representative at each site. SAP
SMEs would also be valuable as they would provide our team with internal
expertise and knowledge to ensure SAP is aligned to our business processes and
needs.
Overall, the information provided
will be useful in ensuring the success of our next ERP implementation. A combination of the recommended courses of
actions will provide our team with quantifiable benefits which will result in
success and overall savings for our team.
I look forward to working with you on our next ERP implementation,
please advise if you would like to further discuss and review next steps for
our team.

